header image
 

PHONOGRAM review

First let it be established that I am by no means an expert on comic books. I read few of the super hero serials as I grew up (it’s an aspect of childhood far less common than in the states). I did read a few of Spiderman, quite a lot of Hulk, the occasional X-Men, and a few ‘themed’ graphic novels or one-offs that could be found in my local library. I was initially fond of Peter David, whom I stumbled into from his Star Trek novels, a childhood fascination of mine. Even then, David’s were just a little bit less rubbish to my developing snobrain (new word!)

More recently, I’ve made a point to catch up where it counts- Warren Ellis (in particular Transmetropolitan), as well as classics like Watchmen and some of the more celebrated Batman books (Dark Knight Returns and so on). I’m currently working my way through Neil Gaiman’s Sandman. If only my dissertation wouldn’t keep interrupting me. Oh, and Next Wave rocks. COME TO PAIN MOTHER.

So, as any decent comics fan will tell you, I am very much a newbie. Interestingly, I’m also probably exactly the sort of casual reader that comic books could really do with attracting. I may be a symptom of broadening appeal and pigeonhole disintegration. Which is new for me, I think.

masthead.jpg

Anyway, Phonogram. I read it yesterday, and it didn’t come out very long ago. It’s essentially a protracted essay on the way that music constructs us, the Britpop movement taken as a particular example. In the vivid, wonderfully pretentious world evoked by writer Kieron Gillen and artist Jamie McKelvie, music is the same thing as magic, manipulated by two groups- phonomancers, like our protagonist, and retromancers, who are to all intents and purposes the baddies. When the semi-deity patron-queen of Britpop, Britannia, disappears, David Kohl is ‘recruited’ to find out what’s going on. But his own intense personal connection with the Britpop era is involved as well, especially when Kohl realises that his own past is at stake…

It’s a quick and very easy read. Gillen subjects us to a niche culture without ever descending into the worst of geekiness, and the book is never less than accessible. The art is very clean and crisp, with a sort of graphic-design sensibility running throughout. The combination is very effective, and will surely sweeten the pill of all the philosophy which the tale carries along with it, as we deal with the nature of personal construction and, implicitly, art itself.

Happily, it all coalesces to a bit of a classic comic-book ending (insane cultists must be STOPPED!). And Kohl himself is pleasingly arrogant, the supporting cast witty enough to keep the whole thing bubbling along nicely. Laugh-out-loud moments are few, I suppose, though I’ve been spoiled by Next Wave lately.

Perhaps the greatest impact Phonogram had for me was strictly personal. I grew up during the height and tale-end of the Britpop phenomenon (I remember Common People being the first time I enjoyed watching Top of the Pops). I was only old enough to start appreciating the whole thing by the very end. I was actually rather fond of Kula Shaker, a band I stole from my older sister and which (amusingly) comes in for a pretty rough ride in Phonogram. But I also remember owning an Echobelly cassette, and my love affair with Blur kicked off pretty early. And, of course, Britpop has informed much of the music I listen to today, and my retrospective approach to many of the classics of that age is more important to me musically than any delving with truly contemporary bands. In short, Britpop was the first cultural phenomenon that I was actually aware of; the first tiny way in which I understood that there was a zeitgeist to be tapped into.

Now look what’s happened. Thanks to this comic, I’ve started digging it all out again. And it’s great.

Part of this is also because I associate Kieron Gillen quite strongly with my mid-teen interests. He’s cut his teeth as an excellent games reviewer. Specifically, he once wrote a Dear John letter to Descent 3. I don’t think I’ll ever forget that.

Anyway, if you want to see the first proper step in imbuing 90s Britain with a character, look no further. A great graphic novel, and especially worth the attention of anyone who’s even vaguely interested in music.

Here’s a nice preview to get you started.

~ by simonkaye on 15 September, 2007.

3 Responses to “PHONOGRAM review”

  1. You really like the transmetro,dont you? I mean, cant blame you, I love it to, just… lol..

    Anyway.

    You kinda gave your comic there a bad rap, unintentionally I guess. Why would anyone not from britian give a flying fuck about how the place was i nthe 90’s? I mean, its not history yet, and its waaaaay not current. How often in my daily travels will I talk to someone about how the UK was like culturally 12 years ago?

    NEVAR.

    Go read DMZ ya jerk.

  2. Great review. I actually came about britpop in a similar fashion, but I was a bit too young to actually appreciate it while it was happening. I stumbled across an old Elasitca album I had for god knows whatever reason a few years ago, wondered who “Dan Abnormal” was, and everything kind of blossomed out of that.

    And I wasn’t exposed to Gillen until last year, when I accidentally read a review of Rainbow Six, nearly pissed myself laughing, and have gobbled up everything he’s written since. In a weird bit of nerdity–a friend of mine was reading Phonogram in skinnies at the time, and it wasn’t until I picked up the trade that we both realized that the videogame journalist/comicbook writer we had both been trying to set each other on for the past six months had actually been the same person.

    Anyhow, sorry to ramble. I clicked your name randomly from a forum comment on RPS (I post as Leeks!), and I’ve been absorbing your musings for the past twenty minutes or so. Good stuff. I also liked your–somewhat long–essay on Bioshock.

    Take it easy,

    K

  3. I’m just glad you dropped in, Kyle. Phonogram was excellent. Haven’t had a chance to look at Suburban Glamour yet, though… hell, haven’t had a chance to update this site in god knows how long.

Leave a Reply